THEBLACKBOOK AUDIT

Mediaite

Our investigations stand on Mediaite's reporting. This page collects every story of theirs we cite, every page on this site that uses it, and how we graded each claim built on it.

The reporting we cite

9 stories, each opening at its source.

Where their work appears on this site

How we graded the claims built on their work

7 FACT · 3 PROBABLY TRUE · 1 SOME SMOKE. A grade is our reading of the public record on one claim, not a verdict on the person.

  1. A former RNC chairman and Trump-endorsed Senate nominee turns up twice: a registered child-sex offender led the prayer at his rally, and another had a role in his state party.

    FACT
    Projection →
  2. At the Jan 14, 2020 CNN debate, the moderator framed a question on a claim Sanders had just denied — as though it were settled.

    FACT
    Thumb on the Scale →
  3. In 2026, CNN built a special around a strategist’s open ‘contempt’ for the progressive left.

    FACT
    Thumb on the Scale →
  4. In 2026, Penn went on Fox to explain how the Muslim progressive Abdul El-Sayed would lose.

    FACT
    The Permanent Pollster →
  5. Lutnick said data centers 'don't use water' and pointed at cows instead.

    FACT
    Data Centers, Cows, and Your Water →
  6. Penn is a mercenary power broker who monetizes ‘the center’ and brands the left as unelectable.

    PROBABLY TRUE
    The Permanent Pollster →
  7. The antagonism predated the 2020 peak: in July 2019 an MSNBC analyst said Sanders ‘makes my skin crawl.’

    FACT
    The Freakout →
  8. The death toll as a 'magic number,' and 'legal grounds for firing.'

    PROBABLY TRUE
    The Editor-in-Chief →
  9. The false claim serves the data-center industry, not the public.

    PROBABLY TRUE
    Data Centers, Cows, and Your Water →
  10. Vance said that if his work leads to the end times, 'OK' — and if it builds a lasting world, 'great too.'

    FACT
    “OK With the End Times” →
  11. Whether Netanyahu personally got and buried this specific warning is credible but unproven.

    SOME SMOKE
    The Warning He Didn't Pass On →