THEBLACKBOOK AUDIT
Subscribe
← All essays
Essays on Essential Questions · No. 02

Could They Just Frame Us?

If Toka can alter camera footage, and Palantir and Flock can track us, could the government that buys all of it just frame whoever it's threatened by?

Black Book Audit ·

In December 2022, the Israeli newspaper Haaretz reviewed the internal pitch materials of a company called Toka. The header on them read "Discover, Hack, Alter." Toka sells governments the ability to break into security cameras and change what they recorded, and its materials describe doing it without leaving a forensic trace on the device. The known customers include the United States. (Toka, graded FACT.)

Hold that next to two more facts. Police across the country can now track where your car goes and who showed up at a protest. And the agencies buying these tools are the same agencies that decide who gets charged.

So here's the question. If the government can watch anyone, and can buy the power to change the recording, what stops it from framing whoever it decides is a threat?

The watching is already routine

Flock Safety runs a network of license-plate cameras used by thousands of police departments, and any department on it can search across the others. Officers have used it to stalk exes and romantic rivals. A Texas sheriff's office ran a nationwide search that it logged as related to an abortion. Local departments have handed access to ICE and Border Patrol, getting around their own cities' sanctuary laws. More than fifty cities have canceled or suspended their contracts since 2025. (Flock Safety, graded FACT.)

In September 2026, 404 Media published leaked Flock training materials. In a company webinar, a Flock manager walked police through monitoring a No Kings protest against Trump in Denver, using live crowd feeds, plate-reader alerts and a search across jail and warrant records to justify a harsher response. The Electronic Frontier Foundation found more than fifty cases of agencies searching Flock data for protests and activist groups, and 404 Media counted more than 4,000 searches justified with "ICE" or "immigration" in a single year. Flock says its tools exist to solve crime and that agencies decide how to use them. Our page doesn't claim anyone was arrested for protesting because of Flock. (Flock Taught Cops How to Watch a Protest, graded FACT.)

The phone in your pocket is covered too. Paragon Solutions, an Israeli spyware firm with former Prime Minister Ehud Barak on its board, sells a tool called Graphite that reads encrypted apps like WhatsApp and Signal. In April 2026, the acting director of ICE confirmed to Congress that ICE uses it. In January 2025, WhatsApp disclosed a Paragon campaign against about ninety journalists and members of civil society, and an Italian parliamentary committee confirmed Italy's government used Graphite against activists. (Paragon Solutions, graded FACT.)

The journalist Antony Loewenstein documents how Israel's defense industry uses the occupied territories as a proving ground and markets its surveillance abroad as "combat-proven." Israel's own defense ministry reported optical surveillance jumping from about 6% to about 22% of its record arms exports. Palantir, which announced a partnership with Israel's defense ministry in 2024, holds major contracts for American immigration enforcement. (The Palestine Laboratory, graded FACT.)

Changing the record is for sale

Watching tells the state where you were. Toka is the part that could change what the record says. Its pitch describes altering camera footage, and in February 2026 Haaretz reported that it had built a car-hacking product with microphone activation and dashcam access. Toka says it has dropped that tool from its 2026 plans. TechCrunch confirmed in December 2024 that Toka is going after American federal contracts. The venture firm of the investor Marc Andreessen led its first funding round. (Toka.)

We know of no case where Toka's tools were used to fake evidence against anyone. That's the honest state of the record. It's also the problem, because a change that leaves no forensic trace is a change nobody can prove.

Governments have faked the enemy before

This wouldn't be new. Forging an opponent's voice, planting a provocateur or staging an attack and pinning it on someone is one of the oldest tricks in politics, and both parties' operatives have used it. Our page on the tactic finds that states and intelligence services are its heaviest users. The FBI's COINTELPRO program forged Black Panther letters. The Soviet KGB invented the story that the United States created AIDS. (The Call Is Coming From Inside, graded FACT.)

What would stop it

Put the pieces side by side. The government is the customer for the watching and the altering. It decides who gets investigated. Its agencies already search these systems for protests and for immigration cases, sometimes against local law. And when a recording is the evidence, the defense has to trust the same government that bought the power to change it.

Nothing here proves anyone has been framed. The question is what would catch it if someone were. Two things would help: a public list of every agency that buys tools able to alter digital evidence, and a rule that any footage used in court comes with a record of every system that touched it. Ask your city council and your members of Congress whether either exists. Read the record above and decide for yourself.

The record behind this essay

  1. Toka: the Israeli firm that sells governments the ability to alter camera footage, and the American venture capital that funds itFACT
  2. Flock SafetyFACT
  3. Flock Taught Cops How to Watch a ProtestFACT
  4. Paragon Solutions: Ehud Barak's third surveillance venture, run by a former Unit 8200 commander, now inside US immigration enforcementFACT
  5. The Palestine Laboratory: field-tested on Gaza, sold to the worldFACT
  6. The Call Is Coming From InsideFACT