THEBLACKBOOK AUDIT
Subscribe
← All essays
Essays on Essential Questions · No. 01

Why Wouldn't They Try Again?

If a congressional committee found that Wall Street men planned to march 500,000 veterans on Washington to sideline FDR, and no one was prosecuted, why wouldn't they try again?

Black Book Audit ·

In November 1934, the most decorated Marine in America sat before a committee of Congress and testified under oath that a bond salesman had asked him to lead 500,000 veterans on Washington. The goal was to push President Franklin Roosevelt aside and put a man answerable to business in charge of the government. Three months later, the committee reported that the plan was real. Nobody was ever charged.

That's the whole question in one paragraph. If the people behind it paid no price, what would stop the same kind of people from trying again?

What the record says happened

The Marine was Major General Smedley Butler, twice awarded the Medal of Honor. On November 20, 1934, he told the House's McCormack-Dickstein Committee that Gerald MacGuire, a bond salesman earning $100 a week, had pitched him on the march. Roosevelt would stay on as a figurehead. A new "Secretary of General Affairs" would run the country. Wealthy backers would pay for it.

MacGuire wasn't freelancing. He worked for Grayson M-P Murphy & Company, the firm of a banker tied to J.P. Morgan, and a Singer sewing-machine heir named Robert Sterling Clark paid for his trip to Europe. Butler also named bigger figures, including John W. Davis, Morgan's chief lawyer, and Thomas Lamont, a Morgan partner. In the same months, the same circle of money founded the American Liberty League, a public campaign against the New Deal that got about 30% of its money from the du Pont family. (The Plot to Seize the White House, graded FACT.)

On February 15, 1935, the committee gave its finding: "There is no question that these attempts were discussed, were planned, and might have been placed in execution when and if the financial backers deemed it expedient." It said MacGuire's letters to Clark backed Butler up.

Then it stopped. The committee called Butler's testimony about the famous names "hearsay" and never called them in. MacGuire denied everything and died a few months later. No prosecutor took up the case.

The New York Times had already called Butler's story a "gigantic hoax." After the committee reported, the same paper ran a headline that said "Plan for March on Capital Is Held Proved."

Historians still argue about how close it came. Arthur Schlesinger Jr. called it a "cocktail putsch," mostly talk. We grade it PROBABLY TRUE that it was a serious, funded scheme. Either way, the committee's finding stands, and so does the part that matters here: nobody paid anything.

What happened when big money backed the other side

The American plot failed. In Germany, the same kind of move worked.

In November 1932, about twenty industrialists and financiers, among them Gustav Krupp and a representative of the chemical giant IG Farben, petitioned President Hindenburg to make Adolf Hitler chancellor. On February 20, 1933, industrialists tied to IG Farben, Krupp, Telefunken and Osram pledged roughly two to three million Reichsmarks to the Nazi election campaign. (It Has a Rulebook, graded FACT.)

The consequences didn't stick there either. After the war, John J. McCloy became the American High Commissioner for occupied Germany. Between 1949 and 1952 he used his clemency power to reduce or commute (shorten) most of the sentences handed down by the Nuremberg Military Tribunals. He freed Alfried Krupp, whose factories ran on slave labor, and restored his fortune. Then McCloy came home and ran Chase, the World Bank and the Ford Foundation. (The Man Who Freed the Nazis, graded FACT.)

So the record runs two ways. In America, the money men who planned a coup were never charged. In Germany, most of the sentences that followed the war were cut within a few years, and Krupp got his fortune back. Neither outcome teaches anyone with a fortune that this kind of thing is dangerous to try.

Would they need 500,000 veterans today?

Probably not. A march on Washington is loud, illegal and easy to stop. The 2020s version is none of those things.

Some of the most influential voices in the tech industry have written their plan down in public. The blogger Curtis Yarvin proposed "RAGE," short for "Retire All Government Employees," and argued for running the country like a company with a CEO-king at the top. The investor Marc Andreessen's 2023 "Techno-Optimist Manifesto" named "trust and safety" and "tech ethics" as enemies. JD Vance, now vice president, has cited Yarvin and repeated the idea of firing every mid-level government worker. Elon Musk led DOGE, the effort to cut the federal workforce. Russell Vought, an architect of Project 2025, runs the White House budget office. (They Published the Plan, graded FACT.)

None of this is secret, and none of it requires a coup. In 2024, Musk alone spent more than $290 million to elect a president and Congress, about a quarter of a billion of it through his super PAC (a committee that can raise and spend unlimited money as long as it doesn't coordinate with a campaign). That included a $1-million-a-day giveaway to swing-state voters who signed his petition. A Philadelphia prosecutor sued to stop it, and a judge let it run. (The Artificial State, graded FACT.)

The tools a government of that kind would want are already for sale: Flock Safety's network of license-plate cameras, Palantir's data systems, Anduril's autonomous weapons, and Toka's ability to break into security cameras and, according to reporting, alter what they recorded.

Nobody needs a coup when the plan is published and the spending is legal. We don't claim anyone named here is plotting, or that they coordinate. The question is whether the outcome Butler was asked to deliver by force can now be delivered through elections and contracts, with no one breaking a law.

And if they break one anyway?

Here the 1935 lesson comes back. The Business Plot ended without a single charge. Today the federal government has dropped, dismissed or weakened enforcement actions against more than 200 corporations since the start of Trump's second term, according to Public Citizen's tracker. Those same companies have given or pledged more than $210 million to MAGA Inc. and other super PACs aligned with Trump. (The Enforcement Market. The tracker and the money are graded FACT. That the cases were dropped because of the money is graded PROBABLY TRUE, a strong pattern, not proven for any single company.)

When the consequence for planning to overthrow the government was nothing, and the consequence for corporate wrongdoing now can be a cancelled case, the question in the title is a plain question about incentives. Why wouldn't they try again?

Two things would change the answer: prosecutors willing to use subpoenas against the people who pay for power, and a public that remembers 1935. Read the record linked above and decide for yourself.

The record behind this essay

  1. The Plot to Seize the White HouseFACT
  2. It Has a RulebookFACT
  3. The Man Who Freed the NazisFACT
  4. They Published the PlanFACT
  5. The Artificial StateFACT
  6. The Enforcement MarketFACT